Y axis wobbles, Y1 grinds at short distance

My Primo has developed an odd wobble on the Y axis - it seems like it’s vibrating as it moves. The X axis doesn’t have this issue. Additionally, there’s occasional grinding noises from the Y1 stepper as it returns to 0, but only at around 50ish mm or below. Even then, the grinding is short.

I’ve tried different levels of belt tension on the Y1 belt but haven’t had much success yet. My next thought was to remove the belts, re-square the gantry, then reinstall the belts. Is that the right next step to try or is there something else I should look into first?

Video + audio of the issue: https://i.imgur.com/mxQMkI6.mp4

That looks more to me like the motor on that side of the axis isn’t being driven. Possible bad wiring to the stepper (Extension cable come undone?) or bad driver.

Power down the machine, and unplug the stepper for that side from your control board. Then power up and repeat your test. Does it behave the same exact way? Then we’ve found your problem.

1 Like

Both steppers are moving. When moving from 0 to 100, Y1 (left side) is rotating counterclockwise, Y2 (right side) is rotating clockwise.

Both steppers may be moving with the belts in place. That isn’t the question. The question is whether the behavior changes when you’ve disconnected the stepper on the problem side as I mentioned above.

If no change in behavior, you’ve potentially identified that the electronics aren’t driving that stepper and instead it is freewheeling as the overall axis is moving.

Sorry, only in retrospect did I realize A) that came across as dickish B) I neglected to mention that the rotation was with the belts completely disengaged and free from the pulleys. Either way that rotation is under basically no load.

For what it’s worth I powered off, disconnected Y1, moved Y2 normally, then powered off again, reconnected Y1, disconnected Y2, moved Y1 normally, then powered off and reconnected Y2. Maybe loosening and redoing the belts did something because the grinding sound is gone, but the vibration is still there. The entire Y tube shakes whenever Y moves.

I tried to take a closer video - Imgur: The magic of the Internet might be as good as I can get it to show the vibration.

All good. Sometimes I can sound dickish. I mean well :smile: .

OK so the two motors are moving properly. That’s good.

I’ll take a look at your video a little later and see if I have any insight.
We’ll find this.

@MakerJim Any chance you might have some insight into what I can try next?

Sorry that this slipped through and I hadn’t responded.

I’m not sure, so we should pitch this back to the community.

Other MPCNC builders- what do you see in that video that can hint to next troubleshooting steps?