Which Prusa printer would be your first... if you had a $400 coupon/discount?

I finally managed to get enough points on Printables to get that $400 discount toward a Prusa printer.

I’ve owned quite a few printers, but never a Prusa.

The coupon is almost enough to get the Mini+. It’s a hefty discount on a Core One, and I really lean that way. I could perhaps swing an XL, and I like the fact it’s multiple extruders instead of a single extruder with an MMU. But the XL is pricey and the options for number of extruders are 1, 2 or… 5.

I welcome input from current / former Prusa owners. Or even from those watching who have not dived in yet.

UPDATE (about a hour later): Thanks everyone for the helpful advice. This has both confirmed my lean toward the Core One, and basically tipped me over the breaking point on going that route! I’m going to pull the trigger on it! — Core One on the way.

2 Likes

PS: I don’t know how long I can restrain myself from making a decision that involves pulling the trigger on a purchase… so if any of you have opinions or advice, please chime in. I’d prefer to get your counsel before I wear down and pull a trigger. LOL.

I think mini would be my last choice. You already have “better” printers than that.

Probably core one or if I hated money that week an XL

1 Like

The Prusa Pro HT90 comes with a free MK4S right now. :laughing:

1 Like

At that price it better come with a free space shuttle!

1 Like

Personally this seems like a good balance? Two gets you main material + soluble support, then five if you want to go nuts. It took me a while to remember that people use this stuff for multicolour printing… personally I just use paint (or sometimes manual changes) on the rare occasions I don’t print something that’s function over form.

Anyway. Were it my money, I’d take (almost) 50% off a CORE One kit and not hesitate. I don’t think the XL is bigger than the CORE by enough to spring the extra money, unless you want dual extruders and then it gets more expensive again. And I wouldn’t bother with a mini.

But as I mentioned, the last time I bought a prusa printer (or indeed any printer) was eight years ago, so I’m a fair ways behind the curve of what’s possible now in any case…

1 Like

@FreneticScribbler
Your thought process here is essentially the same as mine, and why I’m leaning strongly toward the Core One. I also don’t see myself in the “go nuts with 4 or 5 colors” mode, although if I had it, who knows. I don’t yet own any of the soluble support filaments. I probably would like a dual extruder setup. But I’m just now remembering, I think I have an old, “past generation” type printer, new, never opened, that could perhaps be a dual extruder type setup, and I’m not sure but I might be able to make it into a “faster” printer. Pondering on that…

1 Like

I absolutely love my MK3s - my MMU2s…I could live without.

When the MMU works - it’s great. But…it only works reliably when I splurge and get more expensive filaments - with my normal workhorse hatchbox filament it’s a crapshoot.

If you want multi material I would go with the XL for sure. If you don’t care about multi-material then I’d go with the core one.

I’d only consider the mini if there was a reason I needed a smaller compact printer.

I got my printer in 2018 as a MK3 with the MMU2 on a black friday sale. The MMU was delayed though so I had several months with the MK3 stock and absolutely fell in love with it. My original printer was a FolgerTech i3 clone and it worked…but I think there were only 2 original pieces left on it by that point and I had to constantly fiddle with it and experiment to find new slicer settings that would work reliably. (At the end it was upgraded to a v-groove motion platform for the Y axis, a e3d extruder/hotend…I forget exactly which but it was the hot stuff at the time, and had gone through several options for bed leveling.)

The Mk3 was almost “toaster” level of simplicity by comparison. I immediately felt it was worth the premium price. The build instructions were outstanding and it went together in an afternoon - then self-calibrated and “just worked” better than my FT ever did.

When the MMU finally arrived I actually put off installing it for a few months - The main reason I wanted it was for dissolvable supports - but with the Mk3 supports printed so much better and were easily removed that I was no longer interested in dissolvable supports. The MMU also required a LOT more space than I expected so I built an enclosure so the filament spools could go on top.

Getting the MMU working was a huge pain. I ended up doing a couple of modifications to it and eventually got it working mostly reliable as long as I only use prusa filament or Atomic filament - any other filament and it was almost a given that it would fail at some point. I never really did multi-filament prints though and just used it to be able to quickly switch between filaments for prints.

Then I got the s upgrade - I’m not sure how much it was…if it even cost me as I don’t see an order for it in my order history. The upgrade was fairly painless and did make the MMU more reliable…but still not enough that I really recommend it.

Especially since when the MMU3 was released they upgraded the firmware and now the MMU is back to being annoying. It does a really loud an obnoxious homing now - hard enough it regularly knocks the idler loose from it’s stepper motor. I’ve ben seriously considering removing the MMU but keep holding out hope a firmware upgrade will get it back to playing well again as I found I do sometimes like to do 2 filament prints to do labeling.

With the textured print bed and multi-color I really like making control panels and such:

All the white panels on my Modular Synth were 3D printed with MMU labels:

The biggest limit is you can’t really get very detailed - the labels on this Cosmac ELF are pushing the limits for how small this works without going to a smaller nozzle:

So - yeah - LOVE my Prusa and would definitely buy another. I’ve been considering doing the MK4 upgrade to my machine but the upgrade paths just don’t compel me. almost $600 for the upgrade with the motors but still being on the 7 year old frame just doesn’t seem worth it. The 3.5s for $250 doesn’t include the new load cell hot end so doesn’t interest me…which leaves me with the $500 3.9s upgrade…and if I’m going to spend that much I may as well go for the full 4s upgrade but then I’m back to not feeling like it’s worth it and I’d be better off saving my pennies and getting a new 4s.

I’d love to go with an XL - that’s the way to do multi material. But I don’t have the room or funds for it. And the Core is great…but again no room or funds to go that route right now either.

2 Likes

I’d probably be more inclined to use multi colour if I had multi extruder instead of wasting filament to purges but even still, I’ve never been drawn to it particularly. Especially not when one could buy three CORE ones for the price of a 5head XL… Four if you want it enclosed!

Prusa are using the CORE One in the current iteration of their print farm, not the XL, so that speaks pretty loud to it being not better, just bigger, I think.

2 Likes

Thanks everyone for the helpful advice. This has both confirmed my lean toward the Core One, and basically tipped me over the breaking point on going that route! I’m going to pull the trigger on it!

3 Likes

I wasn’t really interested in dual extruder until I saw this. I thought someone posted it here but couldn’t find it.

3 Likes

@jeyeager
I had watched that very video a few days ago.

Nice - personally, I just do a manual filament swap for this, but anything more than that single change for different coloured lettering and I’d probably get bored of it…

2 to S and 2.5S was a great upgrade. 2 to 3 and 3 onwards seem far less so. And, personally, I don’t know why you’d get a MK4 over a Core, that extra money ought to pay for itself pretty quick in better efficiency…

1 Like

The purges suck. On the few real multifilament prints I’ve done the wipe tower weighed as much or more than the finished print. I just can’t bring myself to waste that much plastic.

This was my first successful multi-material print…the print was 7g - the wipe tower was 9g:

And - with purges you can’t do true multi-material like that Bellows - because the same thing that makes that work - makes the wipe tower fail.

Multi-extruder is the way to go if you want functional multi-filament printing and not just decorative.

That was the problem…with white on black a single layer doesn’t work - the white is too translucent. So you have to do at least 2-3 layers for the labels to come out decently. Black on white is better - but it still works best if you do 2-3 layers. And I can’t be bothered to swap filament manually that many times.

Oh - one other issue with the MMU - flexible filament is RIGHT OUT. I’d love to do multi-filament prints with TPU integraded only where needed…but…I can’t even do a single filament print with flex in the MMU. I have to bypass the MMU and just load it manually. The filament path just isn’t flex friendly.

When I more seriously considering a 4 upgrade on my 3 the core wasn’t out yet. Came very close to pulling the trigger. Now I’d love to go with the core…just I’m very tight on space and I’m not sure the core will fit well on my lack table stack…

2 Likes

Ah, I just emboss the text, so it can be as many layers as I like after the single change. Your design is cleaner, but yeah, probably not nice with manual changes.

Pretty sure the Core ONE is smaller on the outside, despite being bigger on the inside, than any of the MK series :thinking:

(shilling a printer I don’t even own… how much more do you reckon I need to do before Prusa send me one? :rofl: )

3 Likes

Yes, because no moving bed. :slight_smile: Like, from the front to the back.

1 Like

But I like being able to use my printer as a slingshot! :laughing:

3 Likes

Core One!

1 Like

The XL is nice but $$$$. The Core One is hot and would fit better in your current stable of printers. But an MKS or mini would be great as a gift to someone who was trying to get into 3D printing. I hope you go for the core one.

And I hope you go for the kit. Because it is more fun.

2 Likes

Three layers is exactly right and involves only two colour changes, start with the white lettering and the first is only a few minutes from the start, the next will depend on how much your other colour first layer is, but then two layers of lettering only takes a few minutes and you can leave the print alone for the rest of the time it takes.


And @DougJoseph nicely done! I can’t imagine you’ll regret the Core One - do treat yourself to Prusa filament for a trial and see the results! My Mk4S will become a core one later in the year, and I am yet to decide what to do about the multi material thing. If time miraculously appears next year we shall see!

3 Likes