Could consider using making a mold for them, and casting epoxy pieces with the different elements in them.
C
How thick is it? It’s gorgeous!
Thanks. This is about 3/4 inch (19 mm) thick. I tried doing half that thickness but I didn’t think they felt as solid so I went with thicker.
I didn’t know there was an official 3d version. I plan on making a chest for everything once its all complete. But it’s going to have to be a big box. I’ll try to post it whenever I get around to making it.
Storage was going to be my next question! Looking forward to seeing it
This is cool! I somehow never saw this thread until now. I had recently designed a Catan board that I laser engrave and laser cut out of 1/4" oak, and sell on my Etsy store. Here’s a link to a short video of that board: Catan game board, my own design work, 1/4” oak, 100w CO2 laser - #17 by DougJoseph
Hey Garrett, I have been contemplating doing a Catan made out of wood for ages now and yours cought my eye here as well as on instructables and thingyverse (I am somehow always stumbling over it… 
So I downloaded your files and noticed you cannot auto-trace them in Estlcam since all of the parts are multiple short lines. I converted the main files to single lines so you can program them more easily, here they are:
Edge_two_port.dxf (95.6 KB)
hex_blank_2.dxf (93.5 KB)
port_blank.dxf (86.1 KB)
Edge_one_port.dxf (95.0 KB)
Thanks for the great files! It will still be a while until I can find the time, but you never know. I also want to use different symbols, maybe my kids can draw some. 
That’s awesome! I’m excited to see how it turns out.
I took inspiration from you @ijustlikemakingthing and a couple other places but here is my take on it been a couple months in the making. still need to finish the box for it.
Where did you get the pieces?
they are 3d printed from garrets files
@chaim354 looking good!
My earliest board and my most recent version, are posted here:
I never played this game, but I made a card holder thingy for a colleague a few years ago, nothing nearly as fancy or beautiful as the ones posted above in this thread, but my colleague was quite happy with it so I guess it works fine:
Here are the files, you got the STL and the STEP if you want to mod it.
Catan Card Holder.zip (1.8 MB)
Thanks for sharing this! Downloaded.
Catching up on this old thread and I came across this link. 
Okay now what I want to see is a full size dining table set where the pieces look like just attractive inlaid hexagons on one side and catan pieces on the other.
Looks like a fun game. If I started making a set now maybe I’d be done in time for my kids to be old enough to play in 6 years or so…
This now makes me want to make a giant version of this board. I like the idea of having it two sided so it also can be flipped over and be used as a table. I may just have to look into doing that.