Flattening a slab on the LR4

One of the real advantages of the LR4 platform is its versatility… everything from 2.5D carving to full thickness cutting to slab flattening to sign engraving (and more!) Is possible.

My current project is to make a table out of a 2-2.5" thick live edge maple slab that has considerable “tiger stripe” figure. It’s about 67" long and about 16" wide at the widest so it fits on my 72" x 42" LR4. The slab was somewhat twisted so it necessary to shim it for the first side.

In the following, I plan to show some progress pics and some results, but there’s also a sort of puzzle about which someone here probably has some insight.

To start, I’m using gcode from Jamie’s generator.

For the cutting, I’ve used three bits: a 0.5" straight bit, a 1" diameter, 3 cutter surfacing bit and a 1.5" surfacing bit with 4 cutters. This is where things got interesting, but that comes later.

Before starting, I confirmed that the gantry is pretty level by measuring the z height of my z-probe at the -x and +x extremes, which differed by less than 0.5mm after tweaking. I also attempted to check the x and y tramming of the router using the IDC 12"(!) Tramming jig, which in retrospect was far too long. That seemed pretty bad since it was off by ~6-8mm in both the x and y directions. But I decided to just “go for it” figuring that if there were steps afterward, I could just sand them away.

I did all the machining in the +Z direction as recommended.

This picture shows the result after the first side was flattened using the 0.5" bit with a 10mm stepover. As expected there appear to be “ridges” between each pass; however, these are very subtle and can barely be felt.

To try to decide how important this was going to be, I rigged up a dial indicator in a magnetic mount and attached it to a steel straightedge which was then dragged across the flattened slab. To my surprise, the fluctuations were less that 0.01"!

In the first reply, the attempted machining of the other side of the slab is shown.

Flattening the other side…

After the excellent results on the first side of the maple slab, it was time to try the other side. However this time I wanted to use the special surfacing bit since it’s diameter was 1.5", which I thought would be faster. But after setting things up, and using a 20mm stepover, the results were horrible. This was not because of ridges… the surface felt very flat. However using this bit was burning the material! Badly!

Of course, having maple be burned when cutting is not a new phenomenon, but it simply would not go away no matter how thin a cut, the speed of cutting or the rotating speed of the router. Even after several passes, the burned surface was retained.

Figuring that 1.5" was just asking too much of the LR4, I switched to the 1" diameter surfacing bit. The result was the same… the surface was unacceptably burned, again independent of the cutting depth, speed or router speed.

So then, I went back to the 0.5" straight bit with 10mm stepover, and tried again. Remarkably, this approach was able to clean up the burn marks on a single pass and we are now back in business. The image shows an initial test area and the restart at the left edge, as well as the extent of the burning that resulted from the surfacing bits.

And here is the slab after a single pass that removed 1mm.

Obviously, there still a few more passes needed to clear the corner. (This slab had about 1 cm of twist initially.) And if you look closely, the “ridges” are visible but not perceptible to the touch.

I’ll add some pics as there is more progress, but for now, I’m curious if anyone has any idea why the burning was so bad with the surfacing bits, but non-existent with the straight bit.

What motion was your gcode moving the router with the cutting edge of the surfacing bits leading? Not sure if that makes sense, but dummy me had a bit one time that I tried where it was set up such that my Kobalt router spins in the “wrong” direction for the cutting face. The results were, in retrospect, predictably bad. I don’t think I described this well.

I’ll bet you’ve accounted for that and don’t have that issue.

As an aside, I can’t wait to see what you do with that awesome slab.

I’m not exactly sure what you mean, but the cutting direction was to the “north” which is from bottom to top in the pic. The progression of passes was from left to right in the pic.

So, the surfacing bits were encountering “new” wood on its north and east sides as it moved. But, this is the same as the straight bit except it only has two flutes instead of three or four.

The only explanation I can imagine is that somehow the imperfect tramming is causing some sort of non-ideal contact, and this burning. (However, the tramming is actually not that bad since at the extremes of the 12" jig, the difference in height was less than 10mm, so, across 24", it’s not that bad. )

On the other hand, I did not try cutting in different directions with one of the surfacing bits, and won’t go back and try that now. But what if the trailing edge was only “dragging” instead of cutting? I wonder if that could cause burning since maple is so challenging in this regard…

Yeah, that’s what I’m wondering about.

has ur 4 cutter got 2 straight up and down and 2 on angles , i do lot of slab surfacing and find them a waste of time on hard woods they tend to ride over the wood , i have had slight burn marks once

my standard surfacing tool 39mm 2 flute on hardwoods at 2500-3000mm/m 0.5 -0.75 mm DOP 50 % step over at about 1- 1.5 on router dial , i have also found cutting at about a 30 deg angle can ssurface better with some timbers

once ive got it to right Hight i do 2 final passes at 0.2mm DOP 25% stepover, 1800 mm/m feed running with the grain which takes away the lines

With my 16mm endmill I go at least 8000mm/min while taking off 0.5mm. Otherwise too much heat gets generated. You really gotta go fast. :slightly_smiling_face:

Ok. You asked for it… here it is. Check out that tiger stripe figure. I was not expecting it to be so distinct.

Wow.