A clone so soon?

Well, this is interesting…
Got a Harbor Freight giftcard for my B-Day & went looking around the website yesterday for something to use it on. Went back today, and this was newly announced:

No 1/8" collet or mention of ER-11 compatability, and stated speeds slightly different, but looks like a twin.
Ryan - any insight?
P.S. Anyone in the market - I would NOT consider the Harbor Freight. Even if it were of equal build quality & specs (unknown), the 1/8" collet and ER-11 compatability makes the Kobalt the obvious choice.

6 Likes

OMG!

Couple huge issues. First RPMs are faster, 5,000 doesn’t seem like much but can mean a world of difference.

Also 90 day warranty… :flushed: that’s small even for the makita

Looks like a body clone. Most manufacturers will let other companies use the same mold

Also… Winston Churchill is a fan…

6 Likes

Seems odd to clone a brand new router… wonder what’s going on here.

Is it weird I was hoping to see a LR3 on that page?

9 Likes

With the ones I’ve seen, it’s often the cast parts that are identical w/clones - they slightly change the injection molded plastic parts to differentiate. My Makita clone (Bauer from Harbor Freight) appears identical to a Makita except for the plastic parts. That’s what caught my eye with the Kobalt clone - it seems the plastic parts are the same shape and color. That, and the inclusion of leds - which my clone and others lack.

1 Like

The same pictures is what gets me. Like maybe the same render?

1 Like

Maybe on the box?
As long as they’re cloning…

2 Likes

Well… It says “Compare to DeWalt”, but…

Kobalt, I believe, is made by Chervon, a Chinese company, which is also where Harbor Freight gets a lot of stuff.

Almost all tool brands are really just a handful of tool manufacturers at the top, so very likely they licensed it or manufactured it for them, with some slight changes, and possibly with the agreement that they “target” a compare to with a competitor, of which DeWalt is because that’s a Home Depot stocked brand.

3 Likes

If so, then it’s a clone that misses some of the key elements.

I wonder if this started in the pipeline before the refinements that Ryan and company suggested and the Kobalt one is the later (in design time) engineering refined derivative.

1 Like

Very slight, but enough that you would have to have different castings




2 Likes

Actually I think it might be. I think I sent the very first one back…or I could check. That is funny. Our work cost an extra $10!

2 Likes

lol…but remember…They’ll be $59 with coupons and ITC memberships, etc. once they recoup some costs

3 Likes

Wow that is insane! Used mine as a router tonight. The slow start is very nice when it is in your hand!

2 Likes

By hand?! Like a caveman?!

9 Likes

You’re right - thought I’d done a good side by side of the pics, but clearly not.

Yeah. I needed a quick pocket on a 2x4 so voilla, i had to unbox an get it running!

1 Like

It sure does look like a clone, and the description (even down to two LEDs) sure sounds like a clone!

1 Like

That’s not very Ron Swanson of you

1 Like

I’m pretty sure Ron would disagree with everything this forum stands for lol

Edit: Well…except maybe for this thread Smoking Meat

3 Likes